Network entity selection

ABSTRACT

There are disclosed measures of network entity selection, for example including furnishing an identity of a network entity being pre-selected by a first network apparatus, and providing verification information for said pre-selected network entity identity, enabling to verify whether the pre-selected network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection at a second network apparatus.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION Field of the Invention

The present invention generally relates to network entity selection in a communication system. In particular, embodiments of the present invention relate to network entity selection in a circuit-switched core network of a communication system. By way of the present invention, any kind of network entity may be selected, e.g. media gateways.

Description of Related Art

Currently, standardization work for present and future communication systems generally aims at achieving more convergence, flexibility and technology-independent implementations. Among others, certain efforts are directed to bearer-independent core networks in communication systems. Although the present specification exemplarily refers to the circuit-switched (CS) domain of core networks (CN), the following may also apply to the packet-switched domain of core networks or even network parts other than the core network itself, e.g. a public land mobile network (PLMN).

Notwithstanding the above, FIG. 1 shows an exemplary logical network architecture of a circuit-switched core network, upon which the following description may be based and the described principles may be applied.

Irrespective of the details of FIG. 1, on the one hand there may be any other number of certain elements, and on the other hand there may also be an arbitrary number of intermediate elements there-between (as e.g. depicted in other figures). Although the designations used in FIG. 1 relate to 3GPP (3^(rd) Generation Partnership Project) terminology, it is to be noted that such terminology (also when used hereinafter) is solely intended as an example, and any other elements with different designations according to a different terminology may also be used, as long as the basic underlying principles, conditions and/or premises are comparable. This applies for example to the individual elements as well as to the individual interfaces (reference points) illustrated. In particular, when hereinafter reference is made to media gateways as a non-limiting example for a network entity, any other network entity (i.e. for example a network element or a functional part of a network element) is equally applicable, for example a gateway attached to a session border controller (SBC) that performs IP and/or port conversion but passes media transparently.

The exemplary logical CS core network architecture according to FIG. 1 comprises two mobile services switching centers (MSC), one of which is a gateway mobile services switching center (GMSC). Although monolithic mobile services switching centers may also be used, there are illustrated combined MSC nodes having a decomposed architecture (i.e. Softswitch architecture) consisting of an MSC/GMSC server (G/MSC-S) as a controlling entity and an attached media gateway (MGW), respectively. As an example, the core network is operationally connected with a GERAN (GSM EDGE radio access network; GSM=Global System for Mobile Communications; EDGE=Enhanced Data rates for GSM Evolution) and with an UTRAN (Universal Terrestrial Radio Access Network), as well as with a PSTN (Public Switched Telephone Network).

As a call control protocol within a network architecture such as the CS core network according to FIG. 1, there have been proposed bearer-independent call control (BICC) and a certain modification of the session initiation protocol, namely session initiation protocol with encapsulated ISDN (Integrated Services Digital Network) user part (SIP-I). While both BICC and SIP-I may be regarded as alternatives for call/session control, so-called optimized and deferred media gateway selection procedures have been proposed for call control based on BICC as well as on SIP-I.

In the case of SIP-I-based call control, an optimized MGW selection as currently defined comprises that one node (e.g. a MSC/GMSC server) selects a media gateway (MGW) according to some rules and signals the identity of the selected media gateway in a SIP-I message to another node (e.g. a MSC/GMSC server). Thus, the other node receiving the SIP-I message is enabled to select the same media gateway, if it has a Mc interface to the selected media gateway, thus saving media gateway and transport network resources. A deferred MGW selection as currently defined provides the opportunity for the receiver of a SIP-I message to select the media gateway, which it prefers, and to send back the identity of the selected media gateway to the preceding node in order to enable that node to select the same media gateway. Additionally, the procedures allow the offerer to send a “proposed” media gateway identity to the next SIP-I node, which may be taken into account when the succeeding node seizes a media gateway.

As the optimized and deferred media gateway selection procedures are currently defined to be optional procedures, it is foreseeable that communication systems or networks will comprise both nodes supporting such procedures and nodes not supporting such procedures. This will lead to compatibility problems when en intermediate node within such a procedure is not able to handle respective (Signaling) traffic appropriately.

Further, for the encoding of an identity of a selected media gateway for transmission from one node to another in optimized and deferred media gateway selection, there have not yet been defined specific procedures. This may also lead to compatibility problems.

One conceivable approach for media gateway identity encoding resides in the use of a session description protocol (SDP) attribute, resulting in that SDP is transported within SIP, or more specifically SIP-I, signaling.

In view of the above-mentioned optionality of both media gateway selection procedures in general and the use of a SDP as a specific encoding for media gateway identities, this means that not every node in a CS CN may understand such a new SDP attribute encoding an MGW identity. According to current SIP procedures, intermediate nodes will transparently forward any unknown SDP attributes, e.g. the one encoding an MGW identity. However, assuming that the originating node MSC A has selected MGW A and has indicated its identity in such a new SDP MGW identity attribute, and an intermediate (call control) node B not understanding the MGW identity SDP attribute forwards that unknown attribute in IP signaling towards a subsequent node and, at the same time, inserts another MGW B, the forwarded MGW identity A may misguide the subsequent node, e.g. MSC C, to select the suboptimal MGW A. This will lead to a configuration where the user plane traffic is transported from MGW A to MGW B and back to MGW A.

It is to be noted that resource savings are at a media gateway handling a call controlled by two servers are only possible, if the call (i.e. the user plane traffic) remains within the same media gateway between the two partitions of the MGW (i.e. “logical MGWs”) controlled by the two servers (e.g. MSC A and MSC B). If on the other hand an MSC server knows that it can not achieve this optimisation, it may use other criteria to optimise the MGW selection, for instance the proximity to the next hop where it decides to route the connection or call to be established (note that, when some kind connection or call is concerned, a network address as mentioned below may also be denoted as connection address).

The above drawbacks are detrimental as to a smooth operation of present and future communication systems and networks in which some kind of media gateway selection is performed.

For overcoming such detrimental effects, it has to be noted that present media gateway selection procedures are defined to be optional. Thus, any solution mandating any node to operate in a certain way (in media gateway selection) is not in line with the optional character thereof, thus being unsuited. In this regard, for example mandatory measures taken for media gateway selection based on BICC are not applicable for media gateway selection based on SIP or SIP-I. This is because applying similar procedures for SIP or SIP-I would require that every node in the core network is mandated to recognize this attribute, which is in conflict with the desired optionality of the procedure. In particular, session border controllers (SBC) acting as SIP-ALGs (application level gateways) may be deployed that insert a user plane entity for IP (Internet Protocol) address conversion and firewalling purposes that does not transcode. At the same time, such SBC may forward unknown SDP attributes transparently.

With respect to the above, it has to be noted that the same or similar drawbacks also exist for the selection of network entities other than media gateway, for example a gateway attached to a session border controller (SBC) that performs IP and/or port conversion but passes media transparently.

Accordingly, there does not exist any feasible solution to the above drawbacks, in particular regarding for example SIP-I-based media gateway selection.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The present invention and its embodiments are made to address one or more of the above-described drawbacks. Thus, the present invention and its embodiments are intended to mitigate drawbacks in network entity selection, for example compatibility problems resulting from the optional character thereof.

According to one exemplary aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method of network entity selection, comprising furnishing an identity of a network entity being pre-selected by a first network apparatus, and providing verification information for said pre-selected network entity identity, enabling to verify whether the pre-selected network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection at a second network apparatus.

According to further developments or modifications thereof, one or more of the following applies:

-   -   the method further comprises transmitting the pre-selected         network entity identity and the verification data to the second         apparatus in a session initiation protocol message,     -   the furnishing of the identity comprises encoding the         pre-selected network entity identity in a session description         protocol attribute, and the providing of the verification         information comprises adding a network address of the         pre-selected network entity to said session description protocol         attribute, and/or     -   the method further comprises defining a network address of the         pre-selected network entity as session description protocol         connection data, and transmitting the thus defined network         address as session description protocol connection data in a         session initiation protocol message.

According to one exemplary aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method of network entity selection, comprising obtaining an identity of a network entity being pre-selected by a first apparatus and verification information for said pre-selected network entity identity, and verifying, on the basis of the verification information, whether the obtained network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection.

According to further developments or modifications thereof, one or more of the following applies:

-   -   the method further comprises receiving the pre-selected network         entity identity and the verification data in a session         initiation protocol message,     -   the session initiation protocol message contains the         pre-selected network entity identity and a network address of         the pre-selected network entity in a session description         protocol attribute, and a network address of the pre-selected         network entity as session description protocol connection data.     -   the method further comprises retrieving the network address of         the pre-selected network entity from the session description         protocol connection data, and the obtaining of the verification         information comprises obtaining the network address of the         pre-selected network entity from the session description         protocol attribute,     -   the verifying comprises comparing the obtained network address         in the session description protocol attribute and the retrieved         network address of the session description protocol connection         data with each other,     -   the method further comprises using the obtained network entity         identity for network entity selection, if the comparison yields         that the compared network addresses are equal, and discarding         the obtained network entity identity, if the comparison yields         that the network addresses are not equal, and/or     -   the method further comprises removing the session description         protocol attribute from the session initiation protocol message.

According to any one of the above-mentioned aspects, the network address of the pre-selected network entity may comprise an Internet protocol address for a communication via said network entity, and/or the method may be performed by a mobile services switching center apparatus, and/or the method may be performed in a circuit-switched core network of a communication system, and/or the network entity may be a media gateway.

According to one exemplary aspect of the present invention, there is provided an apparatus, comprising means for furnishing an identity of a network entity being pre-selected by a first network apparatus, means for providing verification information for said pre-selected network entity identity, enabling to verify whether the pre-selected network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection at a second network apparatus.

According to further developments or modifications thereof, one or more of the following applies:

-   -   the apparatus further comprises means for transmitting the         pre-selected network entity identity and the verification data         to the second apparatus in a session initiation protocol         message,     -   the furnishing means comprises means for encoding the         pre-selected network entity identity in a session description         protocol attribute, and the providing means comprises means for         adding a network address of the pre-selected network entity to         said session description protocol attribute, and/or     -   the apparatus further comprises means for defining a network         address of the pre-selected network entity as session         description protocol connection data, the transmitting means is         further configured to transmit the thus defined network address         as session description protocol connection data in a session         initiation protocol message.

According to one exemplary aspect of the present invention, there is provided an apparatus, comprising means for obtaining an identity of a network entity being pre-selected by a first apparatus and verification information for said pre-selected network entity identity, and means for verifying, on the basis of the verification information, whether the obtained network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection.

According to further developments or modifications thereof, one or more of the following applies:

-   -   the apparatus, further comprises means for receiving the         pre-selected network entity identity and the verification data         in a session initiation protocol message,     -   the receiving means is configured to receive a session         initiation protocol message containing the pre-selected network         entity identity and a network address of the pre-selected         network entity in a session description protocol attribute, and         a network address of the pre-selected network entity as session         description protocol connection data,     -   the apparatus further comprises means for retrieving the network         address of the pre-selected network entity from the session         description protocol connection data, and the obtaining means         comprises means for obtaining the network address of the         pre-selected network entity from the session description         protocol attribute,     -   the verifying means comprises means for comparing the obtained         network address in the session description protocol attribute         and the retrieved network address of the session description         protocol connection data with each other,     -   the apparatus further comprises means for using the obtained         network entity identity for network entity selection, if the         comparison means yields that the compared network addresses are         equal, and means for discarding the obtained network entity         identity, if the comparison means yields that the compared         network addresses are not equal, and/or     -   the apparatus further comprises means for removing the session         description protocol attribute from the session initiation         protocol message.

According to any one of the above-mentioned aspects, the network address of the pre-selected network entity may comprise an Internet protocol address for a communication via said network entity, and/or the apparatus may comprise a mobile services switching center apparatus and/or the apparatus may be located in a circuit-switched core network of a communication system, and/or the network entity may be a media gateway.

According to one exemplary aspect of the present invention, there is provided a computer program product comprising program code means being arranged, when run on a processor of an apparatus, to perform any one of the methods according to any one of the above aspects.

According to one exemplary aspect of the present invention, there is provided a data structure comprising a session description protocol attribute containing an identity of a media gateway and a network address of the media gateway.

According to one exemplary aspect of the present invention, there is provided a data structure comprising a session initiation protocol message containing an identity of a media gateway and a network address of the media gateway in a session description protocol attribute, and a network address of the media gateway as session description protocol connection data.

Further aspects, embodiments and modifications according to the present invention and its embodiments are set out in respective dependent claims.

By way of exemplary embodiments of the present invention, a network entity to be selected may for example be a media gateway.

By way of exemplary embodiments of the present invention, there is for example provided at least one way to detect an incompliance between a network entity (e.g. media gateway) identity or identifier being pre-selected at one network apparatus, where the selected network entity identity or identifier is passed via an intermediate node to another network apparatus, and the received network entity identity or identifier to be used in the network entity selection process at the other network apparatus. Such a detection may for example comprise that the one network apparatus provides means for indicating such an incompliance, and that the other network apparatus is able to recognize the incompliance by way of the thus provided means.

By way of exemplary embodiments of the present invention, there are for example provided certain measures to avoid that a network entity (e.g. media gateway) selection at a network apparatus (such as e.g. a mobile services switching center) is misguided by a network entity (e.g. media gateway) identity or identifier from an preceding node, as well as measures to avoid a need to support the network entity (e.g. media gateway) identity or identifier (i.e. its selection and/or encoding) in all nodes or network apparatuses in a communication system or network.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

In the following, the present invention will be described in greater detail by way of non-limiting examples with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which

FIG. 1 shows a logical network architecture of a circuit-switched core network where exemplary embodiments of the present invention may be applied,

FIG. 2 shows a flow diagram of a first method according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 3 shows a flow diagram of a second method according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 4 shows a flow diagram of a third method according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 5 shows a flow diagram of a fourth method according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 6 shows a signaling diagram of an optimized media gateway selection according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 7 shows a signaling diagram of an optimized media gateway selection with an intermediate node according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 8 shows a signaling diagram of a deferred media gateway selection according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 9 shows a signaling diagram of a deferred media gateway selection with an intermediate node according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 10 shows a schematic block diagram of a first apparatus according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 11 shows a schematic block diagram of a second apparatus according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention,

FIG. 12 shows a schematic representation of a first data structure according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention, and

FIG. 13 shows a schematic representation of a second data structure according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS OF THE PRESENT INVENTION

The present invention is described herein with reference to particular non-limiting examples. A person skilled in the art will appreciate that the invention is not limited to these examples, and may be more broadly applied.

In particular, the present invention and its embodiments is mainly described in relation to a circuit-switched (CS) core network (CN), which may be defined according to 3GPP specifications, used as a non-limiting example for a network configuration. As such, the description of the embodiments given herein specifically refers to terminology which is directly related thereto. Furthermore, the present invention and its embodiments is mainly described in relation to media gateway selection, although a selection of any kind of network entity or network element is equally applicable. Also, SDP and SIP terminology is used for session signaling purposes, while any other session signaling mechanism may also be utilized as long as compliant with the described features. Such terminology is only used in the context of the presented non-limiting examples, and does naturally not limit the invention in any way.

For the basic logical network architecture exemplarily underlying the following exemplary description, reference is made to FIG. 1.

Stated in general terms, embodiments of the present invention relate to a verification of a network entity (e.g. media gateway) identity to be possibly used in a network entity (e.g. media gateway) selection procedure. To this end, embodiments of the present invention comprise, among others, examples of methods and apparatuses and software and data structures, which are configured for signaling network entity (e.g. media gateway) identities between network apparatuses or nodes. As one non-limiting example, such embodiments may be configured for a signaling based on a session initiation protocol (SIP), e.g. a session initiation protocol with encapsulated ISDN user part (SIP-I), wherein for example session description protocol (SDP) data is transported. Such a signaling may for example occur between mobile services switching centers (MSC), whether implemented in a monolithic or combined manner (in the latter case between mobile MSC servers), in a circuit-switched core network e.g. of a public land mobile network (PLMN) according to current standards (e.g. by 3GPP, ETSI, or the like).

In the following, for the sake of simplicity, the term “media gateway” is used as a non-limiting example for any kind of network entity, without restricting the described teaching thereto.

FIG. 2 shows a flow diagram of a method according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.

According to the method of FIG. 2, an identity of a pre-selected media gateway (MGW) is furnished (operation S201), and verification information is provided (operation S202). The thus provided verification information is associated with the selected MGW identity and enables a network apparatus receiving the MGW identity and the verification information to verify whether the thus received media gateway identity is applicable for MGW selection at that apparatus. Thus, it may be avoided that a receiving network apparatus is misguided in media gateway selection in that an identity of a pre-selected media gateway (chosen at a sending network apparatus) is somehow altered or made ambiguous during the transmission from the sending network apparatus to the receiving network apparatus. Accordingly, the method of FIG. 2 may preferably be performed at an originating side of a media gateway selection procedure, e.g. at the first network apparatus (e.g. MSC), or at the sending side of any intermediate network apparatus (e.g. MSC) in MGW selection.

That is, the method of FIG. 2 describes a way how to indicate to a remote network apparatus (e.g. MSC) that a MGW identity transparently passed (e.g. via an intermediate node) through a network is not applicable for media gateway selection at the remote network apparatus.

FIG. 3 shows a flow diagram of a method according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention. For the thus depicted method, it is exemplarily assumed that the MGW identity is transported in a SDP attribute within a SIP or SIP-I message.

According to the method of FIG. 3, an identity of a pre-selected media gateway (MGW) is furnished by way of encoding the pre-selected MGW identity in an SDP attribute (operation S301), and the verification information is provided by way of adding a network address of the pre-selected media gateway to an SDP attribute as well, i.e. a network address chosen for a corresponding connection or call to be established (note that, when some kind connection or call is concerned, a network address as mentioned below may also be denoted as connection address). Although not being limited thereto, the network address (connection address) may be an IP (Internet Protocol of any conceivable version, e.g. IPv4 or IPv6) address of the pre-selected media gateway, which is used to transport user plane traffic. Furthermore, the pre-selected MGW identity and a network (IP) address of the pre-selected media gateway may be incorporated in the same SDP attribute/extension or distinct SDP attributes/extensions associated with each other. Such an attribute may for example be a session level attribute or a media level attribute. A network address can for instance be a “connection address”, as transferred in the SDP c-line according to in RFC 4566. Alternatively, any other conceivable parameter or message field for transportation of these elements may be used instead or in addition to an SDP attribute. In operation S303, a network address of the pre-selected media gateway (e.g. IP address) is defined as SDP connection data. Namely, according to current SDP procedures, the network address (e.g. IP address) for the corresponding connection or call to be established is included in a respective parameter. For the purposes of the present description, it is assumed, although not being limiting, that this parameter is the “c-line” according to SDP specifications. The network address included in the SDP “c-line” (operation S303) is naturally the same as the network address added to the aforementioned SDP attribute (operation S302). Subsequently, an SIP (more specifically, SIP-I) message is transmitted in operation S304, which contains at least the selected MGW identity and the verification information (i.e. IP address, for example) as SDP attribute, and preferably also the defined network (IP) address as the SDP “c-line”. The message may contain this attribute either in an SDP offer or SDP answer. Accordingly, the method of FIG. 3 may for example be performed at an originating side of a media gateway selection procedure, e.g. at the first network apparatus (e.g. MSC) performing MGW selection, or at the sending side of any intermediate network apparatus (e.g. MSC) in MGW selection.

FIG. 4 shows a flow diagram of a method according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.

According to the method of FIG. 4, an identity of a pre-selected or recommended media gateway (MGW) and verification information associated with this MGW identity are obtained in operation S401. In operation S402, it is verified whether the pre-selected network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection at the apparatus performing the present method, i.e. a second network apparatus. Thus, it may be avoided that the receiving second network apparatus is misguided in the media gateway selection process in that an identity of a pre-selected media gateway intended to be used is somehow altered or made ambiguous during the transmission from the sending network apparatus to the receiving second network apparatus. Accordingly, the method of FIG. 4 may for example be performed at a terminating side of a media gateway selection procedure, e.g. at the second network apparatus performing a MGW selection process, or at the receiving side of any intermediate network apparatus (e.g. MSC) performing a MGW selection process.

FIG. 5 shows a flow diagram of a method according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention. For the thus depicted method, it is exemplarily assumed that the MGW identity is transported in a SDP attribute within a SIP or SIP-I message.

According to the method of FIG. 5, an identity of a pre-selected or recommended media gateway (MGW) and verification information associated with the pre-selected MGW identity are received in a SIP or SIP-I message (operation S501), and then are obtained therefrom, namely from a SDP attribute thereof (operation S502). The message may contain this attribute either in an SDP offer or SDP answer. According to a non-limiting example, which corresponds to the non-limiting example according to the method of FIG. 3, the received message contains the pre-selected media gateway identity and a network address of the pre-selected media gateway in a SDP attribute, and a network address of the pre-selected media gateway as SDP connection data, wherein the network address may preferably be an IP address. If so, which is assumed here, operation 502 obtains a network (e.g. IP) address of the pre-selected media gateway as the verification data. In the thus received SIP or SIP-I message, according to current SDP specifications, SDP connection data is included e.g. in a SDP “c-line”, wherein this connection data in the “c-line” may be altered by intermediate nodes on the passage between the sending network apparatus and the receiving network apparatus. This connection data, e.g. namely the network address of the pre-selected media gateway, is also retrieved from the connection data, i.e. “c-line” (operation S503). Then, for verifying the received MGW identity, in operation S504, the network (IP) address in the SDP “c-line” is compared with the network address in the aforementioned SDP attribute. If the comparison of operation S504 yields that the network addresses are equal, i.e. the received MGW identity is applicable for MGW selection, the received MGW identity is used for MGW selection (operation S505). Otherwise, if the comparison of operation S504 yields that the network addresses are not equal, i.e. the received MGW identity is not applicable for MGW selection, the received MGW identity is discarded and not used for MGW selection (operation S506). In any case the received SDP attribute containing the pre-selected MGW identity and the IP address of the pre-selected MGW identity, as added by a sending network apparatus, may be removed from the SIP or SIP-I message (operation S507. Optionally, which is not shown in FIG. 5, the thus modified SIP or SIP-I message may be forwarded to another node or network apparatus. Accordingly, the method of FIG. 5 may for example be performed at a terminating side of an apparatus performing a media gateway selection procedure, or at the receiving side of any intermediate network apparatus (e.g. MSC).

For more details concerning the above-described methods of FIGS. 2 to 5, reference is made to the exemplary flow chart of FIGS. 6 to 9.

FIG. 6 shows a signaling diagram of an optimized media gateway selection according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.

According to FIG. 6, a first apparatus MSC A requests a reservation of a new termination from media gateway MGW A. MGW A confirms the reservation of that termination and indicates that it allocated network (IP) address IPA to that termination (step 1). It is to be noted that a MGW may contain several interfaces with separate IP addresses. The MSC A thus pre-selects media gateway MGW A, wherein the network address IPA is used for a corresponding call establishment via the pre-selected media gateway. In step 2, MSC A generates a SIP or SIP-I message, in this case SIP INVITE, and transmits it to a subsequent node B. The thus transmitted message contains, as a non-limiting example, encapsulated SDP including a SDP “c-line” (“c=”) reciting the network address IPA assigned by MGW A according to normal SIP/SDP rules and a SDP attribute (“a=”) called “mgwid” reciting both a unique pre-selected (thus recommended) MGW identity MGWIDA and an added network address IPA corresponding to the pre-selected media gateway as verification data. When receiving this message, among others, the MSC B determines on the basis of the “c-line” content, i.e. IPA, the destination for media (i.e. user plane traffic). Also, the content of the “c-line”, i.e. IPA, is found to be equal to the content of the verification data in the SDP attribute, i.e. IPA. Hence, it is found that the received media gateway identity MGWIDA in the SDP “mgwid” attribute should be used for the media gateway selection process. It also determines that it has a control interface towards MGW A and decides to request the reservation of resources at this media gateway. It instructs the MGW to reserve resources for a termination that sends media towards IP address IPA and to reserve resources for another termination (step 3). Media gateway MGW A determines that IP address IPA for the first termination is an own IP address and configures some internal shortcut to connect that termination with the termination reserved in step 1, thereby saving external transport resources and internal processing resources. In step 4, MGW A confirms the reservation of the resources and indicates that it allocated network (IP) address IPA2 to the second termination. For the purposes of continuing the call setup, node B itself may generate a corresponding SIP or SIP-I message for forwarding, in this case a SIP INVITE (step 5). In this message, network address IPA2 is inserted in the SDP “c-line”. The message may also include a SDP attribute “mgwid” as mentioned before.

Thus, according to the operation of FIG. 6, MSC A is configured to perform any one of the methods of FIGS. 2 and 3 at the sending side, while node B is configured to perform any one of methods of FIGS. 4 and 5 at the receiving side as well as any one of methods of FIGS. 2 and 3 at the sending side.

FIG. 7 shows a signaling diagram of an optimized media gateway selection with an intermediate node according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention. It is assumed that the intermediate node B does not support MGW selection based on SIP or SIP-I with MGW identity encoding according to SDP.

Steps 1 and 2 of FIG. 7 are equivalent to those of FIG. 6. In contrast to node B of FIG. 6, node B of FIG. 7 does not have an interface with media gateway MGW A, but with media gateway MGW B using network address IPB. Node B, which e.g. is a SBC or SIP-ALG, that does not support optimized MGW selection and the related “mgwid” attribute, receives the SIP INVITE message from MSC A and ignores the “mgwid” attribute. It inserts an own MGW B, which may either be in the same physical entity as the node B or in a splitted separate physical entity. The MGW B may for instance be inserted for IP version conversion or as a media plane firewall and may pass media without transcoding. Node B instructs the MGW B to reserve resources for a termination that sends media towards IP address IPA and to reserve resources for another termination (step 3). MGW B confirms the reservation of the resources and indicates that it allocated IP address IPB to the second termination (step 4). According to SDP procedures, the node B inserts this network address IPB in the SDP “c-line” (because of being willing to establish a call or connection via its associated media gateway MGW B), but transparently passes (i.e. does not change) the SDP attribute which is deemed to be unknown at node B (step 5). The subsequent node MSC C has an interface with media gateway MGW C. When receiving the message sent by intermediate node B, among others, the MSC C determines that the content of the “c-line”, i.e. IPB, is not equal to the content of the verification data in the SDP attribute, i.e. IPA. Hence, it is found that the received media gateway identity MGWIDA shall not be used for MGW selection. Rather, MSC C recognizes that optimized MGW selection is not applicable, removes the SDP attribute from the received message. Further, MSC C selects media gateway MGW C, which selection may for instance determine a MGW in an optimised location with respect to the next hop where MSC C routes the call. MSC C instructs the MGW C to reserve resources for a termination that sends media towards IP address IPB and to reserve resources for another termination, and MGW C confirms the reservation of the resources and indicates that it allocated IP address IPC to the second termination (steps 6 and 7). Then, it inserts its network address to its associated media gateway MGW C into the SDP “c-line”, i.e. IPC, and forwards this generated SIP or SIP-I message (step 8). The message may also include a SDP attribute “mgwid” as mentioned before

Thus, according to the operation of FIG. 7, MSC A is configured to perform any one of the methods of FIGS. 2 and 3 at the sending side, node B is configured to not perform any one of the methods described herein, and MSC C is configured to perform any one of methods of FIGS. 4 and 5 at the receiving side as well as any one of methods of FIGS. 2 and 3 at the sending side.

FIG. 8 shows a signaling diagram of a deferred media gateway selection according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.

According to FIG. 8, a first apparatus MSC-A decides to apply the deferred MGW selection procedure and not to select or pre-select a MGW at this stage. MSC A indicates to the subsequent node B that MSC A will not select or pre-select a media gateway. This is effected by sending a SIP INVITE request to the subsequent node, e.g. MSC B. The SIP INVITE request contains encapsulated SDP containing a “c-line” with unspecified IP address (0.0.0.0). MSC A can also decide to recommend a media gateway and to indicate the identity of the recommended MGW B using a new SDP attribute “mgwid”. According to the present embodiment, the value of this SDP attribute contains the same unspecified IP address as in the “c-line” and in addition a unique identification MGWID B of MGW B (step 1). Upon reception of the SIP INVITE message from MSC A, MSC B compares the IP address in the SDP “mgwid” attribute with the IP address in the corresponding SDP “c-line”. As both IP addresses are equal, the MSC B uses the MGW identity MGWIDB in the SDP “mgwid” attribute for the selection of the media gateway. It determines that it has a control interface towards MGW B and decides to request the reservation of resources at this MGW. MSC B instructs the MGW B to reserve resources for two interconnected terminations. MGW B confirms the reservation of the resources and indicates that it allocated IP address IPB1 and IPB2 to the terminations (step 2). According to FIG. 8, network address IPB1 is used for continuing the session initiation process in steps 3 and 4. In step 5, MSC B configures MGW B to send media using network address IPC. It is to be noted that steps 3 to 5 may be replaced by some other signaling, e.g. ISUP (ISDN user part) signaling or signaling towards a mobile terminal.

In step 6, node B generates a SIP or SIP-I message, in this case SIP 183 Session Progress, and transmits it to MSC A. The thus transmitted message contains, as a non-limiting example, a SDP data part including a SDP “c-line” (“c=”) reciting the network address IPB2 assigned by MGW B according to normal SIP/SDP rules and a SDP attribute (“a=mgwid”) reciting both the pre-selected or recommended MGW identity MGWIDB and an added network address IPB2 corresponding to the pre-selected or recommended media gateway as verification data. According to the present embodiment, the value of this new SDP attribute “mgwid” contains the same IP address IPB2 as in the “c-line” and in addition a unique identification MGWIDB of media gateway B. When receiving this message, among others, the MSC A determines on the basis of the “c-line” content, i.e. IPB2, that the content of the “c-line”, i.e. IPB2, is equal to the content of the verification data in the SDP attribute, i.e. IPB2. Hence, received media gateway identity MGWIDB is used for MGW selection. It determines that it has a control interface towards MGW B and decides to request the reservation of resources at this media gateway. It instructs the MGW B to reserve resources for a termination that sends media towards IP address IPB2 (step 7). MGW B determines that IP address IPB2 is an own IP address and configures some internal shortcut to connect that termination with the termination reserved in step 2, thereby saving external transport resources and internal processing resources.

Thus, according to the operation of FIG. 8, both MSC A and MSC B are configured to perform any one of the methods of FIGS. 2 and 3 at the sending side as well as any one the methods of FIGS. 4 and 5 at the receiving side.

FIG. 9 shows a signaling diagram of a deferred media gateway selection with an intermediate node according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention. It is assumed that the intermediate node B does not support MGW selection based on SIP or SIP-I with MGW identity encoding according to SDP.

Step 1 of FIG. 9 is equivalent to that of FIG. 8. Then, some Node B, e.g. a SBC or SIP-ALG, that does not support optimized MGW selection and the related “mgwid” attribute, receives the SIP INVITE message and ignores the “mgwid” attribute. It inserts an own media gateway MGW B, which may either be in the same physical entity as the Node B or in a splitted separate physical entity. The MGW B may for instance be inserted for IP version conversion or as a media plane firewall and may pass media without transcoding. Node B instructs the MGW B to reserve resources for two terminations, and MGW B confirms the reservation of the resources and indicates that it allocated IP address IPB1 and IPB2 to the terminations (step 2). In step 3, node B forwards the SIP INVITE message to a further network apparatus MSC C. The SIP INVITE contains a SDP “c-line” with IP address IPB1. As it does not understand the SDP “mgwid” attribute, node B forwards this attribute without modification. Upon reception of the SIP INVITE message, MSC C compares the IP address in the SDP “mgwid” attribute with the IP address in the corresponding SDP “c-line”. As both IP addresses are not equal, the MSC C does not use the MGWID B in the SDP “mgwid” attribute for the (pre-)selection of the media gateway. It rather selects a media gateway MGW C. The (pre-)selection may for instance determine a media gateway in an optimized location with respect to the next hop where MSC C routes the call to be established. MSC C instructs the MGW C to reserve resources for a termination that sends media towards IP address IPB1 and to reserve resources for another termination (step 4), and MGW C confirms the reservation of the resources and indicates that it allocated IP address IPC1 and IPC2 to the terminations (step 5). In steps 6 to 8, MSC C may forward the SIP INVITE message containing a SDP “c-line” with IP address IPC1, the MSC C may receive a SIP response message, e.g. a “183 Session Progress message”, that contains the SDP answer with an IP address IPD in the “c-line”, and the MSC C configures MGW C to send media towards IPD. It is to be noted that steps 6 to 8 may be replaced by some other signaling, e.g. ISUP (ISDN user part) signaling or signaling towards a mobile terminal.

In step 9, MSC C forwards the SIP response message received in step 7. The SIP response message contains encapsulated SDP containing a “c-line” that indicates IP address IPC2 assigned by MGW C according to normal SIP/SDP rules. The MSC C also indicates the identity of MGW C using a new SDP attribute “mgwid”. According to the present embodiment, the value of this SDP attribute contains the same IP address IPC2 as in the “c-line” as verification data and in addition a unique identification MGWID C of media gateway MGW C. In step 10, node B configures MGW B to send media towards IPC2, and in step 11, node B forwards the SIP response message to MSC A. The SIP response message contains a SDP c-line with IP address IPB2. As it does not understand the SDP “mgwid” attribute, node B forwards this attribute without modification. Upon reception of the SIP response, MSC A compares the IP address in the SDP “mgwid” attribute with the IP address in the corresponding SDP c-line. As both IP addresses are not equal, the MSC A does not use the MGWID C in the SDP “mgwid” attribute for the selection of the media gateway. It rather selects a MGW A. The selection may for instance determine a MGW in an optimized location with respect to the previous hop from where MSC A received the call. MSC A instructs the MGW A to reserve resources for a termination that sends media towards IP address IPB2 (step 12).

Thus, according to the operation of FIG. 9, MSC A is configured to perform any one of the methods of FIGS. 4 and 5 at the receiving side as well as any one of the methods of FIGS. 2 and 3 at the sending side, node B is not configured to perform any one of the methods described herein, and MSC C is configured to perform any one of methods of FIGS. 2 and 3 at the sending side as well as any one of the methods of FIGS. 4 and 5 at the receiving side.

Although “SIP INVITE” and “SIP 183 Session Progress” have been used above as non-limiting examples of messages in which pertinent information may be transferred, it is to be noted that any kind of message may be used additionally or alternatively. For example, any kind of “SDP offer” or “SDP answer” messages may be applied.

Although embodiments of the present invention have been described mainly with reference to methods, procedures and functions up to here, corresponding embodiments of the present invention also cover respective apparatuses, network nodes, including both software and hardware thereof.

The apparatuses depicted in FIGS. 10 and 11 below may be implemented as standalone devices or as constituent parts of devices, network apparatuses, nodes or the like. Both apparatuses shown may also constitute a common system, e.g. by operationally coupled with or without intermediate nodes or apparatuses. Any one of the illustrated blocks represents a certain functionality and may be implemented in any conceivable manner, both in hardware or software or combined. That is, when the term “means for . . . ” is used in the following, any physical implementation is intended to be covered, which is capable of realizing such a functionality. These may for example be any kind of processor, data processing unit, data generator or the like. In this sense, the term “means for . . . ” is intended to have the same meaning and scope as the term “device configured to . . . ”, wherein device may be any kind of physical implementation.

In FIGS. 10 and 11 below, arrows between individual blocks represent operational couplings there-between as well as the direction of data flows on these couplings, and designations in italics represent data transferred on certain couplings.

FIG. 10 shows a schematic block diagram of an apparatus according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention. The thus illustrated apparatus is configured to perform any one of the methods of FIGS. 2 and 3 in a separated or combined manner. That is, also FIG. 10 comprises two levels of detail (the one according to FIG. 2 being depicted by broken lines, and the one according FIG. 3 being denoted by solid lines), these have to be regarded as two distinct embodiments of the present invention.

According to FIG. 10, an apparatus according to the present embodiment comprises means 1010 for furnishing an identity of a media gateway being pre-selected and means 1020 for providing verification information for said pre-selected media gateway identity, wherein the verification information are configured to enable to verify whether the pre-selected network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection at a second network apparatus. Both means 1010 and 1020 are supplied with the necessary information by way of a memory means 1030 storing the pertinent results of a media gateway (pre-)selection procedure. That is, when a media gateway is (pre-)selected, its identity and other data such as network address are deposited in memory means 1030 for future use. The memory means 1030 is operationally coupled with both means 1010 and 1020 and may be of any kind, both permanent and temporary.

The furnishing means 1010 according to the present embodiment is constituted by means 1011 for encoding the pre-selected MGW identity in some parameter for transmission, preferably in a SDP attribute.

The providing means 1020 according to the present embodiment is constituted by means 1021 for adding a network address such as an IP address of the pre-selected media gateway to the thus encoded transmission parameter, e.g. SDP attribute.

The apparatus according to the present embodiment further comprises means 1040 (e.g. sender) for transmitting the pre-selected media gateway identity and the verification data to another apparatus in a session initiation protocol (SIP or SIP-I) message.

According to one aspect of the present embodiment, the apparatus also comprises means 1050 for defining a network address such as an IP address of the pre-selected media gateway as connection data, preferably as SDP “c-line”. If so, the transmitting means 1040 is further configured to transmit this connection data in a session initiation protocol (SIP or SIP-I) message.

FIG. 11 shows a schematic block diagram of an apparatus according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention. The thus illustrated apparatus is configured to perform any one of the methods of FIGS. 4 and 5 in a separated or combined manner. That is, also FIG. 11 comprises two levels of detail (the one according to FIG. 4 being depicted by broken lines, and the one according FIG. 5 being denoted by solid lines), these have to be regarded as two distinct embodiments of the present invention.

According to FIG. 11, an apparatus according to the present embodiment comprises means 1110 for obtaining an identity of a pre-selected media gateway and verification information for said pre-selected media gateway identity, and means 1130 for verifying, on the basis of the verification information, whether the pre-selected network entity identity obtained is applicable for network entity selection at the present apparatus.

According to one aspect of the present embodiment, the apparatus further comprises means (e.g. receiver) 1140 for receiving the pre-selected media gateway identity and the verification data from another apparatus in a session initiation protocol (SIP or SIP-I) message. Such a message may for example comprise the pre-selected media gateway identity and a network address such as the IP address of the pre-selected media gateway in a SDP attribute, and a network address such as an IP address of the pre-selected media gateway as SDP connection data, preferably as SDP “c-line”.

According to FIG. 11, the obtaining means 1110 comprises means 1111 for obtaining the network address of the pre-selected media gateway from the SDP attribute, i.e. means 1111 obtains an IP address from the SDP attribute as the verification data. Further, verifying means 1130 according to one embodiment is constituted by means 1131 for comparing the network address in the SDP attribute, as obtained by means 1110, with a network address in the SDP connection data (e.g. c-line), as retrieved by retrieving means 1120 for retrieving this information from the SDP “c-line”, with each other. Furthermore, the apparatus may comprise means 1150 for using the pre-selected media gateway identity for media gateway selection, if the comparing means 1131 yields that the network addresses are equal (or, stated in other words, the verifying means 1130 yields that the pre-selected network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection), and means 1160 for discarding the pre-selected media gateway identity, if the comparing means 1131 yields that the network addresses are not equal (or, stated in other words, the verifying means 1130 yields that the pre-selected network entity identity is not applicable for network entity selection).

As an alternative, an apparatus according to an embodiment of the present invention may also comprise means 1170 for removing the SDP attribute from the SIP/SIP-I message, irrespective of the result yielded by the comparing means 1170.

FIG. 12 shows a schematic representation of a data structure according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.

As is exemplarily depicted by FIG. 12, a specific data structure according to an embodiment of the present invention may be represented by a SDP attribute or extension containing a data representation of an identity of a media gateway (MGW ID) and a representation of a network address (ADDR) of the media gateway, e.g. an IP address for user plane traffic over the media gateway. Note that an equivalent term for “network address” may be “connection address”.

Hence, according to an embodiment of the present invention, a media gateway identity MGW ID (i.e. a MGW identifier) may exemplarily be encoded as the following “session-level” or “media level” SDP attribute (e.g. called “mgwid”) with the following syntax (in ABNF definition):

-   -   MGW_Identifier=“a=MGW_Identifier: <connection-address> <MGW_Id>”

The sub-field <connection-address>, i.e. the network address, may have the same encoding as defined for the <connection-address> sub-field of the SDP c-line in Clause 5.7 of RFC 4566. The sub-field <MGW_Id>, i.e. the identity of the media gateway, may be an octet string containing any octet value except 0x00 (Nul), 0x0A (LF), and 0x0D (CR). The values are to be interpreted as in a standard character set. It is to be noted that the sub-field <MGW_Id> may be encoded for example in the same manner as BCU-ID in BICC, i.e. 4 Octets for representing Network ID field and Local BCU-ID field. The sub-field <MGW_Id> shall contain an operator-defined unique identifier for a media gateway. Attribute values of the SDP MGW_Identifier attribute shall not be subject to the SDP “charset” attribute.

As is described above, if the <connection-address> sub-field in the MGW_Identifier attribute and the <connection-address> sub-field of the corresponding SDP c-line do not match, an intermediate node not supporting the attribute has inserted something in the user plane, but passed the attribute transparently.

FIG. 13 shows a schematic representation of a data structure according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.

As is exemplarily depicted by FIG. 13, a specific data structure according to an embodiment of the present invention may be represented by a SIP or SIP-I message format containing an identity of a media gateway (MGW ID) and a network address (ADDR) of the media gateway, e.g. an IP address for user plane traffic over the media gateway, in a SDP attribute part, and a network address (ADDR) of the media gateway, e.g. an IP address for user plane traffic over the media gateway, as SDP connection data, e.g. in the SDP “c-line”. It is to be noted that, the network addresses in the SDP attribute and the SDP connection data may be equal or different, and may also be inserted by different entities, as may be seen by way of FIGS. 6 to 9 above.

It is to be noted that the representation of data in FIGS. 12 and 13 is merely illustrative, and may as well be illustrated in horizontal orientation or in any other order. Also, the SDP attribute/extension and the SIP/SIP-I message may contain further elements either in front of those depicted, in-between them, and/or after them.

Any functions, methods and operations described above may of course be implemented by way of software and/or hardware.

In general, it is to be noted that respective functional elements according to above-described aspects can be implemented by any known means, either in hardware and/or software, respectively, if it is only adapted to perform the described functions of the respective parts. The mentioned method steps can be realized in individual functional blocks or by individual devices, or one or more of the method steps can be realized in a single functional block or by a single device.

Furthermore, method steps and functions likely to be implemented as software code portions and being run using a processor at one of the entities are software code independent and can be specified using any known or future developed programming language such as e.g. Java, C++, C, and Assembler. Method steps and/or devices or means likely to be implemented as hardware components at one of the entities are hardware independent and can be implemented using any known or future developed hardware technology or any hybrids of these, such as MOS, CMOS, BiCMOS, ECL, TTL, etc, using for example ASIC components or DSP components, as an example. Generally, any method step is suitable to be implemented as software or by hardware without changing the idea of the present invention. Devices and means can be implemented as individual devices, but this does not exclude that they are implemented in a distributed fashion throughout the system, as long as the functionality of the device is preserved. Such and similar principles are to be considered as known to those skilled in the art.

Software in the sense of the present description comprises software code as such comprising code means for performing the respective functions, as well as software (or a computer program or a computer program product) embodied on a tangible medium such as a computer-readable storage medium having stored thereon a respective data structure or code portions or embodied in a signal or in a chip, potentially during processing thereof.

Generally, for the purpose of the present invention as described herein above, it should be noted that

-   -   an access technology may be any technology by means of which a         user equipment can access an access network (e.g. via a base         station or generally an access node). Any present or future         technology, such as WLAN (Wireless Local Access Network), WiMAX         (Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access), BlueTooth,         Infrared, and the like may be used; although the above         technologies are mostly wireless access technologies, e.g. in         different radio spectra, access technology in the sense of the         present invention may also imply wirebound technologies, e.g. IP         based access technologies like cable networks or fixed lines but         also circuits switched access technologies; access technologies         may be distinguishable in at least two categories or access         domains such as packet switched and circuit switched, but the         existence of more than two access domains does not impede the         invention being applied thereto,     -   an access network may be any device, apparatus, unit or means by         which a station, entity or other user equipment may connect to         and/or utilize services offered by the access network; such         services include, among others, data and/or (audio-) visual         communication, data download etc.;     -   a user equipment may be any device, apparatus, unit or means by         which a system user may experience services from an access         network such as a mobile phone, personal digital assistant PDA,         or computer;     -   method steps likely to be implemented as software code portions         and being run using a processor at a network element or terminal         (as examples of devices, apparatuses and/or modules thereof, or         as examples of entities including apparatuses and/or modules         therefor), are software code independent and can be specified         using any known or future developed programming language as long         as the functionality defined by the method steps is preserved;     -   generally, any method step is suitable to be implemented as         software or by hardware without changing the idea of the         invention in terms of the functionality implemented;     -   method steps and/or devices, apparatuses, units or means likely         to be implemented as hardware components at a terminal or         network element, or any module(s) thereof, are hardware         independent and can be implemented using any known or future         developed hardware technology or any hybrids of these, such as         MOS (Metal Oxide Semiconductor), CMOS (Complementary MOS), BiMOS         (Bipolar MOS), BiCMOS (Bipolar CMOS), ECL (Emitter Coupled         Logic), TTL (Transistor-Transistor Logic), etc., using for         example ASIC (Application Specific IC (Integrated Circuit))         components, FPGA (Field-programmable Gate Arrays) components,         CPLD (Complex Programmable Logic Device) components or DSP         (Digital Signal Processor) components; in addition, any method         steps and/or devices, units or means likely to be implemented as         software components may for example be based on any security         architecture capable e.g. of authentication, authorization,         keying and/or traffic protection;     -   devices, apparatuses, units or means can be implemented as         individual devices, apparatuses, units or means, but this does         not exclude that they are implemented in a distributed fashion         throughout the system, as long as the functionality of the         device, apparatus, unit or means is preserved,     -   an apparatus may be represented by a semiconductor chip, a         chipset, or a (hardware) module comprising such chip or chipset;         this, however, does not exclude the possibility that a         functionality of an apparatus or module, instead of being         hardware implemented, be implemented as software in a (software)         module such as a computer program or a computer program product         comprising executable software code portions for execution/being         run on a processor;     -   a device may be regarded as an apparatus or as an assembly of         more than one apparatus, whether functionally in cooperation         with each other or functionally independently of each other but         in a same device housing, for example.

The present invention also covers any conceivable combination of method steps and operations described above, and any conceivable combination of nodes, apparatuses, modules or elements described above, as long as the above-described concepts of methodology and structural arrangement are applicable.

Even though the invention is described above with reference to the examples according to the accompanying drawings, it is to be understood that the invention is not restricted thereto. Rather, it is apparent to those skilled in the art that the present invention can be modified in many ways without departing from the scope of the inventive idea as disclosed herein. 

The invention claimed is:
 1. A method of network entity selection, comprising: obtaining an identity of a network entity that is recommended by a first apparatus and verification information for said recommended network entity identity provided by said first apparatus; verifying, on the basis of the verification information, whether the obtained network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection at a second apparatus and in response to the verifying that the recommended network entity identity is not applicable for network entity selection at the second apparatus, removing the recommended network entity identity from a message to be forwarded; and receiving the recommended network entity identity and the verification data in a session initiation protocol message wherein the session initiation protocol message contains the recommended network entity identity in a session description protocol attribute, and a network address of the recommended network entity as session description protocol connection data, wherein the verifying comprises comparing the obtained network address in the session description protocol attribute and the network address of the session description protocol connection data with each other and depending on the result of the comparison, using the obtained network entity identity for network entity selection, if the comparison yields that the compared network addresses are equal and discarding the obtained network entity identity, if the comparison yields that the network addresses are not equal, and wherein the network entity is a media gateway.
 2. The method according to claim 1, further comprising: retrieving the network address of the recommended network entity from the session description protocol connection data, wherein the obtaining of the verification information comprises obtaining the network address of the recommended network entity from the session description protocol attribute.
 3. An apparatus, comprising: at least one processor; and at least one memory including computer program code that is executable by the at least one processor, wherein the at least one memory and computer program code are configured to cause the apparatus to perform at least the following: obtaining an identity of a network entity that is recommended by a first apparatus and verification information provided by said first apparatus for said recommended network entity identity, verifying, on the basis of the verification information, whether the obtained network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection at a second apparatus and in response to verifying that the recommended network entity identity is not applicable for network entity selection at the second apparatus, removing the recommended network entity identity from a message to be forwarded; and receiving the recommended network entity identity and the verification data in a session initiation protocol message wherein the session initiation protocol message contains the recommended network entity identity in a session description protocol attribute, and a network address of the recommended network entity as session description protocol connection data, wherein the verifying comprises comparing the obtained network address in the session description protocol attribute and the network address of the session description protocol connection data with each other and depending on the result of the comparison, using the obtained network entity identity for network entity selection, if the comparison yields that the compared network addresses are equal and discarding the obtained network entity identity, if the comparison yields that the network addresses are not equal, and wherein the network entity is a media gateway.
 4. The apparatus according to claim 3, further comprising: retrieving the network address of the recommended network entity from the session description protocol connection data, wherein the obtaining of the verification information comprises obtaining the network address of the recommended network entity from the session description protocol attribute.
 5. A computer program embodied on a non-transitory computer-readable medium, the program controlling a processor to perform: obtaining an identity of a network entity that is recommended by a first apparatus and verification information for said recommended network entity identity, verifying by the first network apparatus, on the basis of the verification information, whether the obtained network entity identity is applicable for network entity selection at a second apparatus and in response to the verifying that the recommended network entity identity is not applicable for network entity selection at the second apparatus, removing the recommended network entity identity from a message to be forwarded; and receiving the recommended network entity identity and the verification data in a session initiation protocol message wherein the session initiation protocol message contains the recommended network entity identity in a session description protocol attribute, and a network address of the recommended network entity as session description protocol connection data, wherein the verifying comprises comparing the obtained network address in the session description protocol attribute and the network address of the session description protocol connection data with each other and depending on the result of the comparison, using the obtained network entity identity for network entity selection, if the comparison yields that the compared network addresses are equal and discarding the obtained network entity identity, if the comparison yields that the network addresses are not equal, and wherein the network entity is a media gateway.
 6. The computer program product according to claim 5, the program further controlling a processor to perform: retrieving the network address of the recommended network entity from the session description protocol connection data, wherein the obtaining of the verification information comprises obtaining the network address of the recommended network entity from the session description protocol attribute. 